Skip to main content

The Importance of the ABC Test and Steps Drivers Can Take to Improve Gig Work

 

Overview

The gig economy has revolutionized the labor market, offering flexible work opportunities but presenting significant challenges, particularly regarding worker classification. The ABC test is a critical legal framework used to determine whether workers should be classified as employees or independent contractors. This classification affects access to benefits, protections, and rights. Recent legislative efforts aim to weaken the ABC test, which could further exacerbate worker misclassification issues.

The Threats to the ABC Test



Several states have robust ABC tests, including California, Hawaii, New Jersey, and Vermont. However, these tests face continuous legislative attacks. For example, California's AB5 codified the ABC test and has been the target of numerous proposed bills seeking to create exceptions for certain gig workers. These proposals often come from platform companies aiming to maintain a business model that heavily relies on independent contractor status to reduce costs.

The American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) has introduced the "Uniform Worker Classification Act," aiming to broadly redefine employee status, thus weakening the ABC test. This act threatens to undermine worker protections across various states, including Oklahoma and West Virginia, by shifting the presumption of employee status away from the worker.

The Importance of Enforcement


Vigorous enforcement of the ABC test is vital to combat worker misclassification. New Jersey is a model state, demonstrating how robust enforcement can lead to significant penalties for companies violating labor laws. For instance, Uber was fined $100 million for misclassifying drivers, showcasing the potential impact of stringent enforcement (Sherer & Poydock, 2024).

New Jersey's legislative approach includes the 2019 Wage Theft Act, which increased liquidated damages for wage theft by up to 200%, created anti-retaliation provisions, and established new penalties for willful misclassification (Wexler & Savadjian, 2019). Additionally, states like Vermont and Nevada have created task forces to address misclassification, emphasizing the importance of dedicated enforcement mechanisms.

Actionable Steps for Drivers

Drivers and other gig workers can take several steps to continue improving their working conditions:

  1. Organize and Advocate: Join or form local worker organizations and unions. Collective action can amplify workers' voices and push for stronger protections.

  2. Stay Informed: Keep up-to-date with local and state legislation affecting gig work. Understanding the legal landscape helps in advocating for beneficial changes.

  3. Report Violations: Actively report misclassification and other labor violations to state agencies. This helps build cases against non-compliant companies and strengthens enforcement efforts.

  4. Support Pro-Labor Legislation: Advocate for and support legislation that strengthens worker protections. Engage in campaigns and vote for representatives who prioritize labor rights.

  5. Educate Fellow Workers: Share knowledge about rights and available resources with other gig workers. A well-informed workforce is better equipped to fight for fair treatment.

  6. Use Legal Resources: Utilize legal aid and worker advocacy groups to challenge misclassification and seek rightful benefits and protections.

Economic Impact of Misclassification



Misclassification has significant economic impacts, not only on workers but also on state revenues. According to the Economic Policy Institute, misclassified workers miss essential benefits like health insurance, paid leave, and unemployment insurance. 

This misclassification shifts the burden of social insurance from employers to workers, reducing overall contributions to social insurance programs such as Social Security and Medicare.

Here is a chart illustrating the estimated annual revenue loss to social insurance programs due to worker misclassification (Schmitt et al., 2023).


Google drive link to download chart

The ABC test remains critical for ensuring fair worker classification and preventing exploitation in the gig economy. As legislative threats continue to emerge, drivers must stay vigilant, organized, and proactive in advocating for their rights. By taking these actionable steps, gig workers can work towards a fairer, more equitable future in the platform economy.



Reference 

Rhinehart, L., McNicholas, C., Poydock, M., & Mangundayao, I. (2021, June 16). Misclassification, the ABC test, and employee status: The California experience and its relevance to current policy debates. Economic Policy Institute. https://www.epi.org/publication/misclassification-the-abc-test-and-employee-status/

Sherer, J., & Poydock, M. (2023, February 23). Flexible work without exploitation: Reversing tech companies' state-by-state agenda to unravel workers' rights and misclassify workers as 'contractors' in the gig economy and beyond. Economic Policy Institute. https://www.epi.org/publication/flexible-work-without-exploitation/

Wexler, H. M., & Savadjian, L. L. (2019, August 12). New Jersey passes landmark anti-wage theft law. Seyfarth Shaw LLP. https://www.wagehourlitigationblog.com/2019/08/new-jersey-passes-landmark-anti-wage-theft-law/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

9 Disturbing Gig App Statistics That Will Make You Rethink Gig Work

Summary: While the gig economy offers flexibility and the potential for higher earnings, it also harbors several significant drawbacks that might make you reconsider diving in. Here are ten concerning statistics that reveal the darker side of the gig app economy. I hope this can be a frame of reference for those who do research and those who use data-driven ways to look at gig work.  1. Earnings Below Minimum Wage There was a time when I was looking to earn extra income, and I went to pick up an order, which was already picked up. The order was from a popular fast-food chain restaurant, and I was disappointed that someone already picked up the order. I could have called the app company I was working for but was in a hurry to keep going. I thought I would be credited for that order like I usually was, but I was not. After that order, I waited for 45 minutes and did not receive any order, I was multi-mapping, but the wait time was longer than average. I was just waiting for free, even b
Post a Comment
Read more

Six Reasons I Can No Longer Recommend The Gig App Economy

Preface: To preface this post today, I want to state that the gig economy is very region-specific, with the Experiences of others being different based on that state in the United States. My expertise, data, and historical facts form my position.  However, I know everyone has a different view on this topic, and I'm not attempting to sway your opinion on gig work. Becoming an independent contractor is much better than being a third party between you and the customer. #1 - Income Instability One of the primary reasons I can no longer recommend the gig economy across all states is the inherent income instability. Unlike traditional employment, gig work often lacks a steady paycheck. This instability can be particularly challenging in states with high living costs. For instance, in states like California and New York, the cost of living is significantly higher, making it difficult for gig workers to cover their basic expenses during lean periods ( Opportunity Atlas ). Data Point: A
Post a Comment
Read more

Decoding Financial Futures: College Education vs. Workforce Entry vs Trade School in 2024 | A Comprehensive Data Analysis

Summary:  Deciding whether to pursue a college education or enter the workforce directly after high school is a significant and complex decision. This blog post analyzes the latest data in 2024 to compare the financial outcomes, career opportunities, personal development benefits, and social mobility prospects associated with both paths. By examining average earnings, unemployment rates, student debt, job market trends, and real-world success stories, we aim to provide a comprehensive overview to help you make an informed choice. Additionally, we delve into the probability of becoming a millionaire with or without a college degree, offering valuable insights into the long-term impacts of this critical decision (We do not give financial advice; this is strictly for educational and informational purposes only). Introduction: The decision to pursue a college degree is among the most significant choices young adults face today. With rising tuition costs, student debt, and evolving job mar
Post a Comment
Read more

Workplace Bullying & Rolling The Day Job Dice

Summary: Many rideshare drivers are moving into working traditional jobs due to the changes taking place in the gig app economy . Traffic is dying down, and many people are waking up to the realities of the gig app economy. This post will cover an essential topic for those re-entering the W-2 economy and working a regular job. The topic we will cover today is workplace bullying, how it plays a significant role in the quality of the work environment and can cause a lot of trouble, and how to improve workplace conditions. Co-Worker Control  In our previous article, we highlighted the 30 million employees who believe that the workplace is toxic. No person is more harmful than the bully in some workplace environments. Here is a person who may have been given a role because others are intimidated by them or something is out of control in their personal life, and they seek to maintain power by controlling/bullying others. According to Dr. Bertrice Berry (2004) " These are people who do
Post a Comment
Read more